|
I thought this book was really
good, because it has a good variation of characters. I have got another of
the Historical House set, called Lizzies Wish, by Adele Geras. I think
that it works well, the way that they have 3 different authors, Ann Turnbull,
Adele Geras and Linda Newbery, writing the set, as they share the jobs out.
It is also really good how they follow that one house, No. 6 Chelsea Walk, and
the lives of the extraordinary people who have lived in it throughout its
history. I would give this book 10 out of 10, because it has an amazing
storyline, and is a great read!!!!!
    
Sine, Kinlochbervie Primary
It was quite interesting. It
didn’t appeal to me.

Terri, Brora Primary
It was old fashioned - not very
good could have done better!!!!!!!!
  
Conor, Brora Primary
It was rubbish for me because I
don’t like opera and it was about a woman who wanted to do opera, but children
or adults might like it depending if they like opera.
 
Shelley, Brora Primary
It’s quite interesting and it
was not funny.
   
Jojo, Brora Primary
It was interesting but there was
no funny or cool things in it.
  
Michael, Brora Primary
I'm lost for words but I can say
this: It's not very good.
 
Petra, Brora Primary
Maybe it’s because I am a boy
but I found this book very slow and far too talkative. The heroine was extremely
stuck-up and annoying and the incessant singing was really frustrating. However
it might appeal to girls as all the main characters are female and therefore
easier to empathise with.

Patrick, Achfary Primary
|